Skip to content

Free shipping on orders $50+ · Free pickup in Millbrook Shop cookies

Comfort cooki
0 items in cart

Cart

Your cart is empty.

Quarter pound cookies

Quarter pound cookies

19 products 19 products

Filters

Products

  • Chunky Chocolate chip

    Chunky Chocolate Chip

    5.0 · 12 reviews

    The classic, done the way it should be. Crisp, golden edges give way to a soft, gooey middle packed with big chunks...

  • Biscoff Cookie butter cookie

    Biscoff Cookie Butter Cookie

    4.9 · 8 reviews

    A cookie on a cookie, and we're not sorry. This rich, smooth Biscoff cookie butter cookie is loaded with creamy white chocolate...

  • Extra Cookies and Cream

    Extra Cookies and Cream

    5.0 · 2 reviews

    A childhood favorite, all grown up. We fold crushed Oreos into a soft, crisp-edged chocolate chip cookie, then pile chunky Oreo pieces...

  • Peanut butter choco chip

    Peanut Butter Choco Chip

    5.0 · 3 reviews

    Salty, sweet, and seriously satisfying. This soft, thick cookie is packed with creamy peanut butter and studded with rich chocolate chips, the...

  • Crownie (Brownie filled chocolate chip cookie)

    Crownie (Brownie Filled Chocolate Chip Cookie)

    5.0 · 2 reviews

    Can't choose between a cookie and a brownie? Now you don't have to. The Crownie is a golden chocolate chip cookie, crisp...

  • White chocolate macadamia

    White Chocolate Macadamia

    5.0 · 3 reviews

    packed with crunchy toasted macadamia nuts and white chocolate for the perfect balance of sweet and savory.

  • Snickerdoodle

    Snickerdoodle

    HUGE soft on the inside snickerdoodle with browned butter for extra depth of flavor and of course they are rolled in my...

  • Double Chocolate Chunk

    Double Chocolate Chunk

    5.0 · 3 reviews

    For the true chocolate lover. We start with a rich chocolate dough and pack it with big chocolate chunks, so it's deep,...

  • Oatmeal chocolate chip

    Oatmeal Chocolate Chip

    5.0 · 4 reviews

    Cozy in cookie form. Hearty oats give this thick, soft-baked cookie a satisfying chew, and rich chocolate chips melt into every bite....

  • Matcha white chocolate toasted macadamia nut

    Matcha White Chocolate Toasted Macadamia Nut

    5.0 · 1 review

    Not your everyday cookie, and that's the point. Matcha (green tea powder) meets smooth, creamy white chocolate and crunchy nutty toasted macadamia...

  • Sugar cookie

    Sugar Cookie

    Simple, done perfectly. Our classic sugar cookie is huge, soft, and chewy, made with real vanilla for a warm, buttery-sweet flavor that...

  • Walnut Chocolate Chip

    Walnut Chocolate Chip

    Big, chunky, and made for people who like a little crunch with their chocolate. Every bite is loaded with toasted walnuts and...

  • Oatmeal raisin

    Oatmeal Raisin

    5.0 · 2 reviews

    Hearty oats, warm cinnamon, and juicy raisins come together in this thick, chewy classic. Made with real butter and brown sugar for...

  • Espresso choco chip

    Espresso Choco Chip

    5.0 · 2 reviews

    Coffee and chocolate, the best duo there is. This homemade espresso cookie is perfectly chewy, with a bold coffee kick and loads...

  • Rocky Road

    Rocky Road

    5.0 · 1 review

    Fudgy, chocolate-packed, and loaded with gooey marshmallows, crunchy almonds, and melty chocolate chunks Fudgy 

  • Pumpkin Spice White Chocolate

    Pumpkin Spice White Chocolate

    Fall in a cookie. This soft pumpkin spice cookie has just enough warm spice to feel cozy without overpowering anything, and sweet,...

  • Pecan cranberry

    Pecan Cranberry

    5.0 · 1 review

    Warm toasted pecans perfectly paired and loaded with cranberry 

  • Classic Sampler

    Classic Sampler

    5.0 · 8 reviews

    Sample our first four flavors double chocolate, walnut chocolate chip, white chocolate macadamia, matcha white chocolate macadamia 

  • Mini chocolate chip cookie goodie bag

    Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie Goodie Bag

    5.0 · 2 reviews

    Big flavor, little bites. Every bag holds 19 homemade mini chocolate chip cookies, each one a perfect big-bite size made with only...